The Supreme Court agreed on Monday, October 18, 2026, to review whether Congress had constitutional authority to ban home distilling of spirits, enacted in 1868. The decision creates a split between lower federal appeals courts that issued conflicting rulings in April 2026.
Where
Federal; case involves Texas-based Hobby Distillers Association and challengers across multiple states
When
Oct. 18, 2026
Sources
Reported by 5 outlets
Taxes and money
The sources don't state an effect on taxes. They do state these figures.
Maximum fine for home distilling violation$10,00034Who pays or receives it: Violators
Who's involved
Supreme CourtAgreed to review the case
Hobby Distillers AssociationPlaintiffs challenging the ban
Robert AltPresident and CEO of Buckeye Institute; attorney for the challengers
John ReamBrewpub owner and plaintiff in Sixth Circuit case
Trump administrationDefending the federal ban
Justice DepartmentAppealed to Supreme Court to defend the ban
The facts
Supreme Court agreed to review the constitutionality of an 1868 federal ban on home distilling of spirits.234Stated by 3 sources
Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the ban unconstitutional in April 2026, calling it outside Congress's taxing power.34Stated by 2 sources
Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the ban's constitutionality in April 2026, calling it a necessary means to collect federal excise tax.34Stated by 2 sources
Home distilling is punishable by up to five years in prison and a $10,000 fine under current federal law.34Stated by 2 sources
Hobby Distillers Association, a Texas-based nonprofit, is among the plaintiffs challenging the ban.34Stated by 2 sources
Attorneys general from 15 Republican-led states filed Supreme Court briefs backing the legal challenge to the ban.3
Supreme Court is expected to hear arguments and issue a ruling by the end of June.3
Who said what
These are statements and claims made by the people involved. They are reported, not verified.
Hobby Distillers Association and other plaintiffs The 1868 law is an antiquated relic of Reconstruction-era politics that Congress overstepped its authority to enact.24
Government attorneys Congress properly restricted home distilling to prevent federal excise tax evasion and lifting the ban would erode congressional powers.4
Robert Alt, plaintiffs' attorney Home distilling is as American as apple pie and the founders would not recognize it as a federal crime.4
Plaintiffs' lawyers Congress could ban a broad array of private home activities under the government's interpretation of the law.4
Where the sources disagree
Whether Congress had constitutional authority to ban home distilling under its taxing power Fifth Circuit ruled it exceeded Congress's authority [3, 4]; Sixth Circuit ruled it was a necessary means to collect federal excise tax [3, 4]
How they headlined it
The same event, as each outlet put it. Marked words appear in only one outlet's headline.
Supreme Court: SCOTUS Decisions & News on the U.S. Federal Court
These outlets were found through Google News headlines. Google decides which outlets appear there, and they lean mostly one way, so this sheet can only be as balanced as the reporting it was built from. Leanings are AllSides Media Bias Ratings.
A federal grand jury in Dallas indicted four Texas residents on charges of promoting a fraudulent trust scheme that sheltered more than $1.5 billion in income from taxation and caused an estimated $200 million in federal tax losses.
$The alleged scheme sheltered more than $1.5 billion in income from federal taxation and caused an estimated tax loss of over $200 million to the U.S. government.
Duncan John MacDonald, Defendant; Sarah Duren, Defendant; Richard Ronald Cayce, Defendant and 2 more
Gov. Greg Abbott announced that Texas employers added 154,300 nonfarm jobs over the past 12 months, with an annual job growth rate of 1.1%, exceeding the national rate by 0.8 percentage points.
$more than $20 million for jobs and Education for Texans career training grants
Corpus Christi placed Proposition B, the "Fair Water Amendment," on the ballot. The measure would amend the city charter to eliminate a drought surcharge exemption for large industrial water users. A coalition gathered over 12,000 verified signatures to add it to the ballot.
$31 cents for drought surcharge exemption fee
Chloe Torres, Coastal Bend regional coordinator, Texas Campaign for the Environment; Roland Barrera, Corpus Christi City Council member at-large; Texas Campaign for the Environment, organization that worked to place measure on ballot
A scheduled search for a missing Texas woman was called off on Oct. 20 before volunteers could begin. Christin Munn Holliday was last seen in Katy on Sept. 29; her BMW was found abandoned after a crash on the Atchafalaya Basin Bridge in Louisiana, and witnesses reported seeing her walk away from the scene.
Republican Mark Keough is running for a third term as Montgomery County judge against Democratic challenger James Graf in the Nov. 3 general election. Keough, who took office in 2019, said he wants to continue building on his accomplishments. Graf pledged to serve just one term and focus on long-term financial planning.
$$480 million for road bond
Mark Keough, Republican candidate for Montgomery County judge, incumbent serving third term; James Graf, Democratic challenger for Montgomery County judge
The Judicial Council of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ordered that all cases of U.S. District Judge Ada E. Brown in Dallas be temporarily reassigned. The council found evidence that Brown abandoned her post and suffers from a mental condition that interferes with her judicial duties. A judicial committee on Tuesday urged her to cooperate and explain why she emailed confidential and sealed court documents to approximately 140 judges, lawyers and media members over the weekend.
Ada E. Brown, U.S. District Judge in Dallas; Judicial Council of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, issued order and decision
Attorney General Ken Paxton's office launched a statewide inquiry into data center water consumption. Official notices were sent to 156 data center developments across 32 Texas counties after state officials noted noncompliance with mandatory environmental reporting requirements and failure to complete the Texas Water Development Board's water use survey.
Ken Paxton, Texas Attorney General; Texas Attorney General's Office, Enforcement agency launching inquiry; Texas Water Development Board, Agency whose water use survey was not completed by data centers
U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. visited JPS Health Network in Fort Worth on Tuesday to announce a new national kidney care plan. The plan focuses on preventing kidney failure, improving dialysis care, and reforming kidney transplantation.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr., U.S. Health Secretary; Tom Engels, Health Resources and Services Administration Administrator; JPS Health Network, public hospital system where announcement was made